I was also on the fence about making steak since it's hard for me to tell how done a steak is while I'm cooking it. I usually like mine medium to medium well done so I end up overcooking them a lot. I added mushrooms to the recipe for more flavor and I'm glad I did because I under-seasoned the steak. Lets just say it looked better than it tasted. I made the recipe again on a separate occasion using more pepper and added butter. Much improved.
We also had crab cakes, spinach salad, and seasoned potatoes on the menu. I thought it was the perfect balance. For dessert, I made panna cotta with strawberry balsamic vinaigrette. Very yummy!